As unlikely as it seems, Eric the saltwater crocodile is shaping up as a potential bellwether for the global iron ore market.
If the flooded mine in a remote corner of Australia that the reptile calls home is reopened and he's evicted, it'll be a signal that iron ore's price plunge is ending.
Back in November, the prospects appeared bleak for Mount Gibson Iron. Its biggest mine, Koolan Island was engulfed by seawater after the collapse of part of the 75-metre wide wall that kept out the Indian Ocean and Eric.
Now with a Bloomberg index of 28 producers, including Vale and Rio Tinto, gaining 12 per cent this month and optimism prices for the steelmaking ingredient may rise from their five year-lows, Mount Gibson is studying whether to fix the wall, drain the pit and restart mining.
"By the time we come to make that decision, we'll be more confident about what the outlook looks like than now," Jim Beyer, chief executive, said by phone after surveying the site. "I'm modestly optimistic."
The price of ore with 62 per cent iron content at the Chinese port of Qingdao has recorded two consecutive weekly gains after touching $US61.20 a metric ton on February 9, the lowest on record dating back to May 2009 according to Metal Bulletin. Prices hit a peak of $US191.70 on February 17, 2011.
Falling Chinese port inventories could be a positive sign for prices, according to Westpac, which sees iron ore rising to around $US75 a ton later this year. HSBC sees prices averaging $US85 in 2015, while Standard Chartered tips $US87 a ton.
Cancellations and postponements of about 22 iron ore projects with 140 million tons of capacity in the past six months may provide a turning point for iron ore producers, according to Bloomberg Intelligence.
"The market fundamentals suggest that the price has to be higher in the long term," said Nicki Ivory, a Perth-based national mining leader at Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu.
Declining currencies in Australia and Brazil, the two largest iron ore exporters, lower oil prices and freight rates that have almost halved in the past year, are aiding producers as they work to cut costs and protect margins, she said.
Koolan Island is located about 130 kilometres north of Derby in the Buccaneer Archipelago off Australia's northwestern coast. It was first exploited by pearling fleets in the 19th century for ballast and mined for about three decades by BHP Billiton, which closed and flooded the site in 1993. Aztec Resources, granted a permit to begin new exploration drilling on the island in 2004, was acquired by Mount Gibson in a takeover completed in 2007.
A decision on Koolan is scheduled by the end of June, once studies on rehabilitation costs are complete. Efforts to ready the site to resume operations would take a further year to 18 months, including moving on the mine's resident crocodile, according to Beyer. Eric was previously evicted in 2006 in advance of a resumption of mining the following year.
"The guys on site were telling me that Eric has appeared back in the main pit again," Beyer said, after visiting on February 5. "Someone spotted him back in there, whether it's Eric or a son of Eric, we just don't know."
It may be too soon to see a revival in prices with more mine closures needed before the over-supplied market reaches a turning point, according to London-based metals researcher CRU. The global surplus will expand to 85 million tons this year from 39 million tons in 2014, according to Australia & New Zealand Banking Group.
Citing the costs involved and forecasts of lower prices, UBS Group and Wilson HTM Investment Group are among institutions that don't expect Koolan Island to reopen. Iron ore may average $US58 a ton in 2015 because of continued additions to supply, ANZ said February 11.
The outlook and prospect of possible future flooding mean "we don't expect the seawall to be rehabilitated," Wilson HTM analyst Phillip Chippindale said by phone from Sydney.
Mount Gibson, which booked a $946 million writedown against Koolan Island and other assets in the light of lower prices in the six months to December 31, is in talks with its insurer over a potential claim as it also evaluates a restart, Beyer said.
A program to fully rebuild the mine's main pit would probably cost $100 million and take about a year, according to JPMorgan.
This includes pumping out about 10 billion litres of ocean water, more than twice the capacity of New York City's Central Park Reservoir.
Rehabilitating the mine for a re-start ranks alongside closure as the most likely outcome of the company's study, JPMorgan analysts led by Luke Nelson said in a February 17 note.
"Mount Gibson clearly has the cash, so they wouldn't need to raise the money," Deloitte's Ivory said. "They would need to do the economics of it and see if it makes sense."
Sourcee:Bloomberg
- metaljunction »
- Metal News
Metal News & Events
METALJUNCTION PUBLICATIONS
Coal Insights (English) Monthly
Coal Insights is a ready reckoner for anyone associated with coal. This publication is aimed at tracking everything related to coal in India.
India Coal Market Watch(English) Monthly
ICMW is a one-stop source for all news, data and research pertaining to coal demand, consumption, stocks, spot- and long-term prices with respect to the Indian Market.
India Steel Market Watch (English) Monthly
ISMW is a brand new high-end steel market report, covering all aspects of the steel industry in India.
Steel Insights(English) Monthly
Steel Insights delves into various facets of the domestic and global steel industry such as market fundamentals, raw material price trends, price forecasts etc.